The poll is based on compiling ratings of dozens of critics
Posted by Matt on 1/29/2017, 1:53 am, in reply to "Didn't the P&J poll used to be an alternative to something?"
Don't blame the poll, blame the general critical consensus.
I guess some years the critics are more like Rolling Stone, and other years are less like it.
P&J takes its votes from a broad enough sampling of critics that it's never going to look carefully manipulated for maximum hipness, like Pitchfork.
Hosted for FREE by Boardhost.
Create your own free message board!