The Strokes - Room On Fire was as good as Is This It. Granted, I'm barely nostalgic for either record, but it's true.
Weezer - Uh, no, Pinkerton is an enormous fan favorite.
I'll always have a soft spot for "Heat Of The Moment" (and--eyes shift both ways--"The Heat Goes On") but if Asia's s/t was really their best then they are one of the worst bands of all time--it sucked!!
Marillion - Misplaced Childhood (I could never get terribly excited about listening to any of their others)