Well...I guess I'm just unpleasable.
The Jamaican tracks bring out what I thought was missing from the album but there was alot to like the overdubs too, especially the funky keyboard. I reiterate that I think it would have been better as a genuine collaboration. At least we have both versions now.
Also, I unequvically still prefer the overdubbed Stir It Up. My favorite song on the album, probably because it's the one where the overdubbed arrangement was unambiguously better.