Have you seen The Night Riders? That's a b-era one I haven't seen that I want to.
I'm guessing the movie you don't like is High Noon. I do like it but I don't think it's the cream of the genre. I know it tends to polarize people.
The best Boetticher/Scott movies are the four written by Burt Kennedy:
Seven Men From Now
The Tall T
Also very good and giving interesting twists on the formula are:
Decision at Sundown
Buchanan Rides Alone
And not bad for the assembly line product that it is but basically disowned by Boetticher because he only made it to fulfill a contract is: