That’s the rule in HS and College. No one had ever considered it would be necessary in MLB
But this was just harmonizing to HS/College rules  Previous Message
a P but then can just be slid over to DH ‘for free’. They just create a position out of thin air that wasn’t there to start the game.
If he wants to stay in the game he should have to slide to a position that exists the whole game, aka they need to start with a DH separate from the P, just like the other team does, and then sub him accordingly
|
|
Message Thread | This response ↓
 World Series - illini222 October 24, 2025, 21:20:58
- Hoerner, Happ, and PCA all win Gold Gloves* - OB25 November 2, 2025, 20:16:15
- I don’t understand how Yamamoto threw 96 pitches Friday and then 34 last night - MC November 2, 2025, 16:12:25
- Umps made a bad call when they gave the Dodgers the run in 11th when the ball went out of play. - Carl Spackler November 2, 2025, 8:27:43
- So many chances for Toronto in both games. Fucking Dodgers….* - Toonces November 2, 2025, 7:45:24
- They never got to show a live cut of Dodger fans cause LAPD was already wilding outside the stadium - RVA November 2, 2025, 1:16:14
- This account never ceases to amaze… - OB25 November 1, 2025, 23:51:14
- Mannnn fuck LA. can’t believe the 9th inning played out like it did * - MC November 1, 2025, 23:46:15
- Amazing. Bummed on outcome obviously. Yamamoto incredible* - cpsteine November 1, 2025, 23:36:26
- Them using Yamamoto like that is going to change a lot of decisions going forward. - OB25 November 1, 2025, 23:26:39
- OK, let’s have that shutdown followed by salary caps* - opossum jenkins November 1, 2025, 23:20:03
- Do the Dodgers have to wait until after the parade before signing Kyle Tucker? - RVA November 2, 2025, 8:14:57
- No. The Dodgers aren’t the problem* - bjl63 November 1, 2025, 23:26:40
- Yep. Dodgers bought themselves some rings. - Illiniphil November 1, 2025, 23:24:45
- You mean Dave Roberts isn't a genius?* - illini222 November 1, 2025, 23:21:34
- fuck salary caps! Owners should just be willing to pay for players* - DanSaint November 1, 2025, 23:21:17
- Yup* - LeatherneckIllini November 1, 2025, 23:20:39
- That sucked. Hated the sac bunt* - John Coctostan November 1, 2025, 23:19:03
- Well that sucks* - OB25 November 1, 2025, 23:18:47
- Sac bunt, eh?* - Sammich November 1, 2025, 23:15:11
- if Dodgers hold on...gotta think Yamamoto is MVP* - DanSaint November 1, 2025, 23:10:20
- Wowzers. How do you groove that? * - illini November 1, 2025, 23:07:41
- Ugh* - PapaDels November 1, 2025, 23:07:29
- Toronto has a major edge in available arms left. - illini November 1, 2025, 23:03:19
- This is peak baseball right now* - illini21 November 1, 2025, 22:54:48
- Why are these guys sliding into home on force out plays?* - Carl Spackler November 1, 2025, 22:53:43
- Blue Jays were so close. Feels like this isn’t going to end well for them* - Ron McDon November 1, 2025, 22:48:13
- Can’t believe he ran that down* - cpsteine November 1, 2025, 22:41:08
- Nice job by pages to recognize injuring a teammate was worth the risk. * - illini November 1, 2025, 22:40:58
- Dots - OB25 November 1, 2025, 22:40:53
- Why were the outfielders so shallow? - Mrap24 November 1, 2025, 22:40:52
- BASEBALL!* - LeatherneckIllini November 1, 2025, 22:40:04
- What a game. What a series* - John Coctostan November 1, 2025, 22:40:03
- Oh my god* - illini21 November 1, 2025, 22:39:50
- Oh my god * - assassin November 1, 2025, 22:39:44
- This would be a terrible way to end the World Series* - OB25 November 1, 2025, 22:38:39
- Heeeee might be safe?* - assassin November 1, 2025, 22:38:27
- Oh my. He got the cleat down just fast enough* - John Coctostan November 1, 2025, 22:38:13
- Drama * - illini November 1, 2025, 22:37:27
- That’s a loud, long out. -* - assassin November 1, 2025, 22:23:30
- This series fucks* - John Coctostan November 1, 2025, 22:20:49
- Walkoff time? * - illini November 1, 2025, 22:19:20
- Sweet sassy molassey* - OB25 November 1, 2025, 22:16:36
- oh biy* - assassin November 1, 2025, 22:16:05
- whoa * - jdl November 1, 2025, 22:15:37
- Is Mookie washed? * - illini November 1, 2025, 21:46:47
- If someone wants to give you an out, TAKE THE OUT - GMAW November 1, 2025, 21:20:58
- Dodgers trainer has been in LA too long * - assassin November 1, 2025, 20:30:34
- Gimenez is a little bitch* - bjl63 November 1, 2025, 20:25:45
- Enough with these interviews during play* - RVA November 1, 2025, 20:24:15
- The Jays are heavy into leather * - PapaDels November 1, 2025, 20:20:44
- Man what a catch* - assassin November 1, 2025, 20:19:22
- And again!* - assassin November 1, 2025, 20:20:27
- x2* - RVA November 1, 2025, 20:20:20
- It’s amazing that no one ever has enough pitching to get through the playoffs anymore. - OB25 November 1, 2025, 20:06:29
- Gimpy ass bichette cost them at least one maybe two runs* - John Coctostan November 1, 2025, 19:44:44
- Why is Ohtani being given extra time to warmup here? That is some bullshit.* - OB25 November 1, 2025, 19:21:25
- If I had to guess I’d say the Jays win big tonight. - QcIlliniFan November 1, 2025, 11:55:11
- I thought the ground rule double was a bad call - TarheelIllini October 31, 2025, 22:38:48
- I’ve found this to be an entertaining series. Hope tomorrow’s a classic. * - illini October 31, 2025, 22:27:34
- Springer left on deck. Ouch* - CWR10 October 31, 2025, 22:14:30
- That’s some of the worst base running you’ll ever see* - John Coctostan October 31, 2025, 22:13:37
- Unreal finish. Holy shit.* - Toonces October 31, 2025, 22:13:36
- I’m late posting this, but ohtanis one handed double in the 8th was absurd - John Coctostan October 31, 2025, 22:10:57
- TURN ON THE BASEBALL* - Carl Spackler October 31, 2025, 22:09:35
- Could we get yet another legendary playoff HR at the SkyDome?* - OB25 October 31, 2025, 22:09:16
- No* - OB25 October 31, 2025, 22:13:09
- Wow, what happened to Dodgers offense?* - RSMBob October 29, 2025, 21:44:27
- Most strikeouts by a rookie in a World Series game for Yesavage. 2024 draft with good early returns - illini222 October 29, 2025, 21:38:52
- Why have there been so many empty seats in Dodger Stadium in the playoffs?* - gullit October 29, 2025, 21:14:19
- G5: Jays hitting Snell hard early.* - SurfTheBoneyard October 29, 2025, 19:32:08
- Second interview between Pujols and the Pads. Interesting* - LeatherneckIllini October 29, 2025, 10:29:30
- Go Jays. Save America* - LeatherneckIllini October 29, 2025, 7:11:02
- All tied up now. * - harb October 28, 2025, 22:07:29
- Huge fan of Ohtani doing both. But it’s kinda bullshit that the rules allow him to start the game as - John Coctostan October 28, 2025, 21:05:41
- LAD/Toronto is a better TV draw than Dodgers/Yankees. Hopefully TV execs remember that - GMAW October 28, 2025, 20:17:24
- LAD/Toronto is a better TV draw than Dodgers/Yankees. Hopefully TV execs remember that - GMAW October 28, 2025, 20:17:12
- I wish my boys were a little older so they could properly bear witness to this run that Shohei is on - CWR10 October 28, 2025, 13:56:29
- Best example ever of why the Manfred Man rule for the regular season was a godsend - OB25 October 28, 2025, 11:14:26
- That was awesome, but I woke up at 4am just amped still. Going to be a long day* - reggiedunlop October 28, 2025, 9:59:02
- I went to bed after the 11th. Damn near played a whole baseball game after that. - Warrin'_Illini October 28, 2025, 9:23:50
- So happy for my little Dodgers* - bbonb October 28, 2025, 7:17:23
- Stayed up for that and had it spoiled while scrolling Twitter by someone at the game. - OB25 October 28, 2025, 1:52:33
- Will Klein saving this game for the Dodgers* - IlliniRunner October 28, 2025, 1:39:18
- I know what you're all thinking, but Los Angeles actually does have quite a few fat ladies.* - complainant October 28, 2025, 1:27:36
- This is such a brutal lineup that the Blue Jays are left with, they look hopeless to score. - OB25 October 28, 2025, 1:04:41
- Strike zone should be the size of a tractor tire at this point. * - doubledown October 28, 2025, 1:03:50
- It was! * - illinijohn October 28, 2025, 2:42:16
- And more* - reggiedunlop October 28, 2025, 0:55:43
- This game is cinema* - reggiedunlop October 28, 2025, 0:38:04
- walking the bases loaded man, I dunno. I dunno* - IlliniRunner October 28, 2025, 0:08:49
- Gotta say, it kinda sucks to see Tommy Edman playing such a big role in this game* - IlliniRunner October 28, 2025, 0:05:13
- Is Wendell Kim down there? What is happening? * - illini October 27, 2025, 22:55:43
- lol, sending that guy with Guerrero on deck* - IlliniRunner October 27, 2025, 22:54:03
- That guys is the starting pitcher tomorrow night* - illini21 October 27, 2025, 21:58:27
- Holy shit Ohtani.* - Toonces October 27, 2025, 21:56:25
- What a game* - John Coctostan October 27, 2025, 21:56:19
- This is great stuff.* - Toonces October 27, 2025, 21:47:41
- Who had Vlad Jr. scoring from first on a single to break the tie?* - illini222 October 27, 2025, 21:45:37
- Man, love a quiet Chavez Ravine* - IlliniRunner October 27, 2025, 20:20:27
- Weak strike call (and a bad one ) costs Jays there* - illini222 October 27, 2025, 19:35:53
- Yamamoto pretty badass* - John Coctostan October 25, 2025, 21:43:36
- “I Bet On Us, You?” - jjlocke923 October 25, 2025, 19:28:26
- Wow* - John Coctostan October 24, 2025, 21:38:26
- Doubled the runs the Brewers scored over 4 games in 6 innings* - illini222 October 24, 2025, 21:35:28
- This Dodger bullpen cannot miss a bat right now. * - illini October 24, 2025, 21:34:51
- Whenever the Blue Jays make the playoffs, they get epic HR’s in that building* - OB25 October 24, 2025, 21:34:00
- Jays knock SNell out in the 6th, 6 hits the first 21 postseaon innings, 8 in 5 tonight* - illini222 October 24, 2025, 21:22:21
« Back to index | View thread » |
on October 28, 2025, 21:10:15, in reply to "Huge fan of Ohtani doing both. But it’s kinda bullshit that the rules allow him to start the game as"