There was BP43, which was incredible. He only had 15 shots, and scored the last 15 points for us, and Ohio State was #5. But that was Weber's last team that ultimately fell apart and the win didn't really actually matter in the grand scheme..

Given the context, at Mackey, and Kylan out, and what this win could mean for the entire season, it tops it.

There was TSJ for 40 in the BTT, which was also huge.

Beyond that I remember Andy Kaufmann had 46 against UW-Milwaukee in 1990, but that game was also double OT.

Malcolm also had a 40 ball in a meaningless non-con win.

Nothing tops Keaton, and second only to Dave Downey's 53.