I like them enough to join the 1 star club. However I can't say I like anything after Vs. except for the very latest album Gigaton (probably a 10/15 and their 3rd best album) which is surprisingly solid album although lacking consistently solid vocal melodies for me to really love it.
The highlight is this Pearl Jam - Dance Of The Clairvoyants
Where Eddie Vedder does a laughingly great David Byrne impression. It's not a particular melodic song. However it has a good groove and it has contrast between the verse and chorus and some interesting layering of vocals in the coda.
Probably the best Talking Head-ish song by a band that isn't Talking Head since Spark's Let's Get Funky