Have always had a difficult time appreciating "Have A Cigar" or "Welcome To The Machine," though the latter inspired a very amusingly bleak, ugly bit of Gerald Scarfe animation that you can watch on Youtube. The second half of SOYCD is very unnecessary. So no, I'd never rate WYWH higher than a 7 out of 10. This opinion that I have of it is the same I would have of it hearing it in high school, in 2000.
I don't entirely hate Smiley Smile either, but it's only of historical interest for a couple listens. I wasn't wild about Wild Honey either, and a few oddballs over the years have sworn by that as a lost masterpiece.