At this point the odds of me ever listening to either album ever again are very small. I've also forgotten most of More, A Saucerful Of Secrets and Obscured By Clouds at this point, which are things I listened to more recently.
I've never been able to remember a note of the Atom Heart Mother" suite.
Your comment about "Dogs Of War" being the most reviled Pink Floyd song has me wondering how many of their songs are really hated...but I guess they'd mostly be on these two albums!!
So yeah, I guess Dream Theater win, because I can still listen to "Disappear," "Misunderstood" and that one part of "The Glass Prison" that I really like. Who woulda thunk it.