From what you've seen? When do DI and DII cross paths, where does anyone see enough games to make a statement like that? My kids were both on DI teams, and I doubt I ever even walked past a DII game; it never happens. Not by choice, it's a scheduling thing. You've either seen DI or DII ball play.

What I do know is that, based on my Experience in Travel and high school, the players I watched who took DI offers were distinctly more skilled than the DII players, period.

Again, are there outliers? Absolutely, but a minimum of 90% of the DI players are better than DII players. Name a DII player that gets picked up in the portal by a P4. Could it happen, maybe.