Can you say something about people who control their estates from beyond their grave? Sometimes, financial so called wealth planners have pecunious people set up trusts called perpetual trusts. Even though illegal in many states, they are legal in enough states to be sucking the money out of the control of the living generation to be directed by the dead generation before them. This has occured quite visibly in two situations in my life so far... in cryonics where the multimillionnaires lock up most of their funds in an out-of-state perpetual trust, called dead hand trust, written up in many financial mazazines and blogs as extremely detrimental to society and in my own family of origin where my relatively pecunius father by virtue of early death at 64 and his overly generous and often acknowledged ontario government burdened pension income was mismanaged by mom then captured by two brothers of five siblings to be locked up mysteriously without any references to anything to the tune now of over a million dollars. Both the multimillionnaire cryonicists and my own dad are operating their funds from beyond their graves, with my mom having lost her mental faculties and my two siblings of five working in lockstep with my dad's apparent legalisms built into the system he contrived to keep the majority of the family inheritance narrowly controlled, including all the data, which excludes me. I'm currently in a situation where I'm now almost 70 and must find a way to distribute my own assets in a will, hopefully later than sooner, but nonetheless, having to think about it it and one thing I'm going to foreswear to NOT do is operating my assets from beyond the grave. How are several ways I can do that?
You've raised some very valid and troubling points about the potential for wealth to be controlled from beyond the grave, and how it can create significant issues for living generations. The phenomena of perpetual trusts (or "dead hand" control) and the feelings of being disinherited or unfairly treated are complex and can have a huge emotional and financial impact.
Here's a breakdown of ways to ensure you *don't* exert undue control from beyond the grave, and instead empower your beneficiaries:
**1. Avoid Perpetual Trusts (and Overly Restrictive Trusts):**
* **The Key Principle:** Your goal is to provide support and opportunity, not to dictate every detail of your beneficiaries' lives.
* **Instead of Perpetual Trusts:** Consider trusts with a definite termination date. This is often a generation-skipping trust designed to benefit grandchildren but ultimately dissolve. States have rules against trusts that tie up assets forever (often based on the "Rule Against Perpetuities," though many states have modified it).
* **Avoid Overly Restrictive Clauses:** Think carefully about any conditions you place on trust distributions. Are they truly necessary, or are they based on your personal preferences and potentially limiting to your beneficiaries? Examples of problematic restrictions:
* "My son can only receive funds if he stays in a certain profession."
* "My daughter can only receive funds if she marries within a certain faith."
* "My grandchildren can only receive funds for education at specific types of institutions."
* These types of clauses can create resentment, limit beneficiaries' choices, and may even be unenforceable.
**2. Give Outright Gifts (with Considerations):**
* **Simplicity and Empowerment:** The most direct way to avoid control is to leave assets outright. This gives your beneficiaries complete freedom to use the inheritance as they see fit.
* **Considerations:**
* **Maturity and Financial Acumen:** Are your beneficiaries responsible with money? If not, some trust planning might still be needed, but it should be designed to support them while allowing them to learn and grow.
* **Vulnerability to Lawsuits or Creditors:** Outright gifts are immediately subject to claims from creditors or in divorce proceedings. A trust can provide some asset protection.
* **Special Needs:** If you have a beneficiary with special needs who relies on government benefits, an outright gift could disqualify them. A Special Needs Trust is a better option.
* **Estate Taxes:** Giving out right gifts is a strategy that may work well with a properly planned estate.
**3. Designate a Flexible and Trustworthy Executor/Trustee:**
* **The Right Person:** The person or institution you choose to manage your estate is crucial. They should be:
* **Honest and Ethical:** Above all, they must be trustworthy.
* **Competent:** They should have the financial and organizational skills to handle the responsibilities.
* **Fair and Impartial:** They should be able to treat all beneficiaries equitably, even if they have personal feelings or relationships with some.
* **Willing to Listen:** They should be open to understanding the needs and circumstances of each beneficiary.
* **Grant Discretion:** Give your executor/trustee *reasonable* discretion within the bounds of your will or trust. Instead of rigid rules, allow them to adapt to changing circumstances and make decisions that are in the best interests of the beneficiaries. For example:
* "The trustee may distribute funds for the health, education, maintenance, and support of the beneficiaries, considering their individual needs and circumstances."
* **Consider a Co-Trustee or Trust Protector:** You could appoint a professional trustee (like a bank or trust company) *and* a trusted family member or friend as co-trustees. This provides oversight and can balance professional expertise with personal knowledge. A trust protector is an independent party you appoint to watch over the Trustee. They have authority to replace the Trustee.
* **Document Your Intentions:** Write a letter of intent to the trustee explaining why you structured the trust as you did and what your hopes are for your beneficiaries.
**4. Open Communication and Transparency:**
* **Discuss Your Plans:** Talk to your family about your estate planning goals. While you don't have to reveal every detail, transparency can help prevent misunderstandings and hurt feelings after you're gone.
* **Be Clear in Your Documents:** Ensure your will and trust documents are clear, unambiguous, and legally sound. Vague or poorly written language can lead to disputes and litigation.
* **Regular Accountings:** If you do create a trust, require the trustee to provide regular accountings to the beneficiaries, so they know how the assets are being managed.
**5. Focus on Empowerment, Not Control:**
* **Think About Your Legacy:** What kind of legacy do you want to leave? Do you want to be remembered as someone who dictated their family's lives from beyond the grave, or as someone who provided opportunities for them to thrive?
* **Provide Financial Literacy:** Help your beneficiaries develop financial literacy skills. Teach them about budgeting, saving, investing, and managing debt. This is a more empowering gift than simply handing them money.
* **Support, Don't Smother:** Offer support and guidance, but respect your beneficiaries' independence and allow them to make their own choices.
**Addressing Your Specific Situation:**
* **Your Father's Estate:** It sounds like you're dealing with a very frustrating situation. If you believe there has been mismanagement, breach of fiduciary duty, or undue influence in the handling of your father's estate, you should consult with a probate attorney in the relevant jurisdiction (Ontario). They can advise you on your legal rights and options, including the possibility of contesting the will or trust. While you may be 70, you do have rights to try and address this problem.
* **Your Own Estate Planning:** Focus on creating a plan that reflects your values and supports your beneficiaries in a meaningful way, without imposing undue control. Don't let your past experiences dictate your actions, but use them as a lesson to make better decisions.
**Important Considerations:**
* **Legal Advice:** Estate planning laws vary by state and province. It's essential to consult with an experienced estate planning attorney to create a plan that meets your specific needs and complies with the relevant laws.
* **Tax Implications:** Estate planning can have significant tax implications. Work with a qualified tax advisor to minimize taxes and maximize the benefits for your beneficiaries.
By focusing on empowerment, clear communication, and avoiding overly restrictive control, you can create an estate plan that benefits your loved ones and leaves a positive legacy. Remember that estate planning is not just about money; it's about relationships, values, and your vision for the future.
13
Responses