I think the matchups argument is a completely valid one. I also think you can't discount common opponents, as it was one of the few real data points I went off. I pulled info from FloArena and TW and it took a long time, but I was hot and bored.
Garver beating Wask and winning Gutcheck was huge, and he looks super strong physically. Perhaps Chance does not tech him. I would still say it's a Major Dec.
Also Olmstead and Ritchie are fighters so they might not get pinned, but they would most likely be tech'ed. To be fair to Newberg, how about we call those Decisions.
I was trying to be fair to both schools. Even if all three of the above matches are decisions, and Evans beats D. Lamer, CV still wins.
Final Score: CV 37 Newberg 24