Career Stats:

Tholl - .264 32 HR
Zedak - .276 36 HR
Nelson .262 41 HR
Dowling - .274 28 HR
Girardot - .297 14HR
Spaid - .395 46 HR
Golembiewski - .348 46 HR. One year left
Stewart - .369 13 HR 3 years left. This is impressive in the Big 12 given their RPI last year
Pupillo - .382 35 HR Transfer to Alabama two years remaining. The jury is out. As it stands Golembiewski has the edge. Let's see Pupillo's SEC average and HR's at the end of two years.

In who's mind is Tholl better? How can you compare Spaid, Golembiewski and Pupillo to the others given they play in the MAC and Missouri Valley. Certainly, all of the above would have killed it at UNI and Miami of Ohio. I'll give Miami of Ohio the edge since they play in the tournament every year and their RPI was 35 last year. UNI just beats everyone up in the regular season and then loses in the conference tournament every year. In addition, Miami of Ohio is a better school.