I don't think they are that similar, but if banning phones made me more effective, I'm all for it.
But for a lot of jobs that people on this board have, cell phones are used as part of the job.  Previous Message It's basically the same concept. All the positives of letting students have limited access to phones in school mirror the positives of letting employees have cell phones in the workplace. Negatives too. Previous Message Restricting cell phone use has become one of the most significant policy shifts in schools in recent years. In just two academic years, what started as an isolated measure in Florida has grown into a national debate involving nearly three dozen states, as well as educators, parents, and researchers. While it's still too early to determine its full impact, the restrictions have already reshaped the daily routines of millions of students. Seventeen states and the District of Columbia began this academic year with new limits on student cellphone use, marking one of the fastest-moving trends in American education policy. With the latest additions, a total of 35 states now have laws or rules restricting phones and other electronic devices during the school day. https://www.techspot.com/news/109168-school-phone-bans-expand-17-additional-states.html
|
Lots of puns, no real answers
|
Message Thread | This response ↓
 Would you support a school phone ban? - biclops Yesterday, 9:10:02
- 10000000%. Started last year here. Huge impact.* - LeatherneckIllini Today, 9:36:40
- Eff yes. It's ridiculous to allow them.* - Stu Today, 9:35:23
- 100p* - gvibes Today, 9:23:03
- Yes, with a caveat they get to check them at lunch. - EffinIllini Today, 9:08:02
- No.* - Chicago1995 Yesterday, 19:32:56
- Yes. With an administration afraid to set rules, it's almost impossible to - OWWDig Yesterday, 17:25:52
- Yep* - TarheelIllini Yesterday, 12:44:46
- We don’t have an outright ban - AintHatin Yesterday, 12:24:14
- Based on what my wife experiences at her school, absolutely. - tvillini Yesterday, 12:13:26
- I want my kids to be able to communicate with me if they need to. Especially - baconface Yesterday, 12:08:10
- I'm surprised they haven't been banned already. - illinilosch Yesterday, 12:07:40
- I’d pay good money to ban em. I’d prefer they didn’t get them back between periods either* - cpsteine Yesterday, 11:43:25
- Playing devil's advocate, would supporters of school phone bans support bans at businesses? - JFG Yesterday, 10:13:15
- I don't think they are that similar, but if banning phones made me more effective, I'm all for it. - longsnapper Yesterday, 10:22:47
- 100%. They are huge distractions - memyselfandillini Yesterday, 10:07:01
- Absolutely. Phones in school are a terrible idea* - longsnapper Yesterday, 9:59:03
- 100 %* - CoronaTheirAss Yesterday, 9:48:15
- As a high school teacher, here's what I'll say. - JFG Yesterday, 9:45:58
- Yes if there is a way to allow use during emergencies.* - SurfTheBoneyard Yesterday, 9:34:50
- The ATL public schools and the privates in town banned them starting last year. - ATL Yesterday, 9:18:29
- Yes* - KCWildcat Yesterday, 9:18:11
« Back to index | View thread » |
on August 24, 2025, 10:22:47, in reply to "Playing devil's advocate, would supporters of school phone bans support bans at businesses?"
- IlliniSax05 Today, 14:46:18